Professor John Finnis's observations for the Austral Conference to mark the 25th anniversary of Natural Law and Natural Rights - - - La lucha por el derecho natural - Libros y Revistas - VLEX 699101033

Professor John Finnis's observations for the Austral Conference to mark the 25th anniversary of Natural Law and Natural Rights

AutorSantiago Legarre/Alejandro Miranda Montecinos/Cristóbal Orrego Sánchez
Páginas27-30
CU AD ERN OS pp . 2 7-30
THE AUSTRAL CONFERENCE TO MARK THE 25TH
ANNIVER SARY OF NAT U RA L LA W A N D NAT U RA L R IG H T S
I greatly reg ret that I cannot b e here among you to offer these re-
flections in person, to benefit from yo ur critical insights, and to enjoy
again the hospitality and friendship that you -an d es pecially Dr Santiago
Legarre- offered me on my first and, regrettably, only visit to these regions,
in Septem ber 2001. Even at a great distance, I feel especiall y pri vilege d
that you are devo ting t hese days to a considera tion or re consideration o f
a book that made its wa y into the pub lic domai n early in 1980, was soon
apprehended by that notable participant in the jurispmdential conversation,
Dr Carlos Ignacio Massini Correas, and began to enjoy a second life in your
translation published here -as is we ll know n to you a ll- in 2000.
Authors have no uniqu ely reliab le insight into the motiv ating or
strategic idea s in their works. But their testim ony is adm issible as ev i-
dence, and so I ven ture to say one or tw o things about w hat I regard
point, first of all, to chapter XI .8 ( esp ecia lly fro m its se cond page on-
wards), discussing the scholastic d ebate about w heth er that impe rium
ow n free ly chosen act pertains to reason
act o f c hoi ce), as Aquinas contends, o r rather, as Gabri el Vas quez and
Francisco Suarez think, to will. On e cannot (i t seems t o m e) h ave r eally
reason and action, unless o ne can rea dily understand wh y XI.8 so firmly
his accused h im o f ineptness and futi lity in po stulating an imp erium o f
reason). The boo k, o f course, neg lects to exp lain a nd defe nd the reality
of free choice, simply taking it for granted; this passa ge is o ne of the
The gap was later filled, more or less, by the defe nce o f free choice in
Funda mental o f Ethics (1983) -wh ich also takes up the Wojtylan and
by the exp ositi on o f human deliberation , in t he footst eps of St Thomas,
in Aqui nas (1998).
27

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba

VLEX utiliza cookies de inicio de sesión para aportarte una mejor experiencia de navegación. Si haces click en 'Aceptar' o continúas navegando por esta web consideramos que aceptas nuestra política de cookies. ACEPTAR